The inheritance shares to my examples as discussed in the contradiction section on calculated by the Islamic web site Al-Fara'id On-line:

One wife, one daughter:

The Result of
Inheritance Calculation


There is no differences opinion (ikhtilaf) among the Salafus Shalih against this problem


Inheritors Number Share Basic Radd Tash-hieh Dalil Remarks
Daughters 1 1/2 4 14 14
  • Dalil 7
    • Wifes 1 1/8 1 2 2
  • Dalil 12
    • Masalah 8 16 16

    Interestingly: The redistribution gives the wife the Qur'anic share only and gives everything else to the daughter. Contrary to this, in the next example the with overshoot shares, the share of 1/8 of the wife is diminished like everybody else's share as well.

    3 daughters, mother, father, (one) wife:

    The Result of
    Inheritance Calculation


    There is no differences opinion (ikhtilaf) among the Salafus Shalih against this problem


    Inheritors Number Share Basic Radd Tash-hieh Dalil Remarks
    Daughters 3 2/3 16 - 48
  • Dalil 6
    • Father 1 1/6 4 - 12
  • Dalil 8
  • Dalil 19
    		• Ashabah
    Mother 1 1/6 4 - 12
  • Dalil 8
    • Wifes 1 1/8 3 - 9
  • Dalil 12
    • Masalah 24 81

    Mother, one wife, one sister:

    The Result of
    Inheritance Calculation


    There is no differences opinion (ikhtilaf) among the Salafus Shalih against this problem


    Inheritors Number Share Basic Radd Tash-hieh Dalil Remarks
    Mother 1 1/3 4 - 4
  • Dalil 9
    • Wifes 1 1/4 3 - 3
  • Dalil 12
    • Sister 1 1/2 6 - 6
  • Dalil 14
    • Masalah 12 13

    An extra example:

    Mother, wife, sister from both parents, sister from mother only, sister from father only:

    The Result of
    Inheritance Calculation


    There is no differences opinion (ikhtilaf) among the Salafus Shalih against this problem


    Inheritors Number Share Basic Radd Tash-hieh Dalil Remarks
    Mother 1 1/3 4 - 4
  • Dalil 9
    • Wifes 1 1/4 3 - 3
  • Dalil 12
    • Sister 1 1/2 6 - 6
  • Dalil 14
  • Dalil 15
    • Sister of the same Father 1 1/6 2 - 2
  • Dalil 15
    • Sister of the same Mother 1 1/6 2 - 2
  • Dalil 13
    • Masalah 12 17

    Back to the inheritance page
    Answering Islam Home Page